11-13-2026
The Wisconsin Library Association holds its Annual Conference in the fall. This year I finally made my way to Middleton and attended two days of the conference. Besides enjoying the food (breakfast, lunch AND snacks), I learned about the work WLA is doing to promote legislative changes regarding ebook pricing.
Any patron who uses Libby to checkout ebooks or audiobooks knows the wait time for popular titles can be months, several months according to the estimated wait time. It’s reasonable to think this could be solved by purchasing more copies. There are several reasons why this solution is not feasible.
To begin, libraries and individuals don’t purchase electronic books. We license them. This means the publisher determines conditions of use. For individuals that may mean you have a limited circle of friends or family who may borrow the book or no one may. That condition can change after the license is paid for. For libraries it means different prices for different licenses.
At one point Kristin Hannah’s The Women was the book to read. Many licenses were purchased (I want to say in the neighborhood of 200) including seven by Prairie Lakes Library System. Not quite three years later only 37 of those licenses remain. The other licenses have expired for one reason or another. Depending on the publisher it could be two years have passed. It could be the copy was checked out 26 times. With 72 people still waiting to read it as of this writing, one has to hope neither of those conditions is met before they finally have a chance to do so.
Publishers justify these metered access conditions as an equalizing factor. Print books sustain damage and are weeded/replaced. Ebooks do not. Just as we replace print books as their condition deteriorates, we should replace ebooks. That argument doesn’t hold up to our collection. ETLPL owns two copies of The Women. One was purchased February 2024, the other donated September 2024. They have been checked out 31 and 29 times respectively and are checked out right now. Neither would be on our shelves if publishers could control the number of years or checkouts allowed with print books.
Ebook pricing is the main factor in the number of licenses libraries have purchased. Publishers charge libraries significantly more for an ebook than individuals. This does not happen with print books. In fact, we usually pay less than list price. Readers First, a global organization of over 300 libraries, conducts periodic research into the cost of select electronic books from the five main publishing houses. Their findings are posted on their website. They show that libraries pay roughly four times an individual’s price for a license that expires. While consumer prices have remained steady or even lowered, library pricing has gone up by as much as 36%. For licenses that expire.
The presenters I saw used Theo of Golden by Allen Levi as an example. Wisconsin libraries have spent roughly $3000 on access to that title. Currently there are 74 copies listed in Libby. At the height of its popularity, $141,000 would have been needed to reduce hold time to five holds per copy. For licenses that expire.
Librarians love publishers. They give us books. They need to make a profit in order to continue doing so. However, the current pricing model is rather rich for the average public library’s budget. WLA is looking to change that.






0 Comments